Start an order

Tell us what you're craving and when you need it. We'll reach out to confirm your order and arrange payment.

Your details

So we can confirm your order.

Your order

Set a quantity for anything you'd like — whole cheesecakes, boxes of minis, or a mix.

Biscoff cookie butter cheesecake slice

Biscoff Bliss

Whole $60 · 6-pack $25 · 12-pack $50

Cheesecake topped with guava jam

Guava Mama

Whole $55 · 6-pack $20 · 12-pack $40

Chocolate cookie cheesecake with chocolate drizzle

Oreo Temptation

Whole $60 · 6-pack $25 · 12-pack $50

Cheesecake slice with salted caramel drizzle

Salted Caramel Affair

Whole $55 · 6-pack $25 · 12-pack $50

Strawberry topped cheesecake slices

Strawberry Delight

Whole $60 · 6-pack $20 · 12-pack $40

Fresh mixed berries

Berry Blush

Whole $55 · 6-pack $20 · 12-pack $40

Pickup or delivery
When do you need it?

We're closed on Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve and Christmas Day — orders for those days can't be placed.

We'll reach out to confirm your order and arrange payment.

The Sugar Collective logo

Handmade cheesecakes, whole or in boxes of minis. Pick your flavors and we'll have them ready for you — for pickup or delivery.

Made to order. Ready when you are.

© 2026 The Sugar Collective · Est. 2026

Good things take time — and cream cheese.